Oil properties and behaviour in water
Step 1 — Remote study with guided digital material
Oil is a toxic substance that persists for a very long time in nature. Understanding the different oil products, their physical and chemical properties, and how oil changes over time is essential to choosing the right response method.
LESSON 1
Oil products
Oil is toxic and breaks down extremely slowly in nature. Once it reaches the sea or shore it harms every kind of organism, from plankton to seals and also people. Crude oil is a fossil fuel found in liquid form in underground formations, between sedimentary rocks and, near the surface, in tar (or oil) sands. Oil products are fuels refined from crude oil and other hydrocarbons found in natural gas; they can also be made from coal, natural gas and biomass.
Crude oil is a mixture of hydrocarbons formed millions of years ago from plants and animals, and has been used as a fuel since the late 1800s. Its colour ranges from black to straw-yellow, and it can be free-flowing or heavy and thick; crude oils differ substantially from each other because their structure depends on how and where they formed. A medium crude oil spill can lose about a third of its volume to evaporation within the first day, but significant residue always remains. Many crude oils emulsify readily, which greatly reduces later weathering, so that stranded crude oil often persists, especially on permeable shore types such as gravel beaches and sheltered habitats like reed beds. Slicks that reach the open sea eventually break up into tar-ball fields, which can travel long distances because they are so persistent. The water-soluble fraction of crude oils contains a wide range of PAH compounds, and dissolution of slicks and stranded oil can take from weeks to years. Freshly spilled crude oil is highly toxic, especially at first, as it releases BTEX compounds (benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene and xylene), which are highly toxic to both the marine environment and response personnel; benzene in particular is very harmful to health, being carcinogenic and potentially neurotoxic, and causes headache, dizziness and malaise even at low concentrations. The most toxic compounds generally evaporate first, so health risks lessen over time although they never disappear completely; sunlight and oxidation can also turn oil into toxic peroxides and acids. At the refinery, crude oil is separated into usable products such as petrol, distillates including diesel and heating oil, jet fuel, petrochemical feedstocks, waxes, lubricating oils and asphalt.
Diesel and other light distillates, such as No. 2 fuel oil, aviation fuels and kerosene, are narrow-cut fractions with low viscosity that spread quickly as thin sheens. Diesel evaporates somewhat more slowly than petrol because of its heavier components and forms a very thin film on the water surface; diesel dispersed in water can bind to fine solids and settle, though in a small spill this is unlikely to cause significant seabed contamination. Diesel has little tendency to form emulsions except in very cold conditions. Being low-viscosity and moderately persistent, light distillates readily break up into subsurface water layers even under light wave action, giving them the highest potential of any oil type for vertical mixing, and a greater chance of dissolving from both the surface film and dispersed droplets; light distillate spills therefore carry the greatest risk to water-column resources. They are not very adhesive, so they do not bind strongly to sediments or shoreline habitats, and shoreline loading is relatively low. Their components are light to medium in molecular weight and break down readily by aerobic microbial oxidation; long-term persistence in sediment is greatest under heavy loading and in reducing conditions where anaerobic degradation is slow.
Petrol and diesel are both light products of the refining process. These light, unstable products generally evaporate relatively quickly; depending on conditions and quality, evaporation is most intense in the first 24 hours and can remove 50% or more of the volume. Because of its very low viscosity, petrol spreads quickly as a thin sheen; its specific gravity is about 0.8, so it forms a thin film and resurfaces quickly if mixed into the water column. Evaporation dominates and can remove almost all spilled petrol within hours to a day, so petrol spills are not persistent: there is little spreading, mixing, settling or accumulation, and no risk of emulsion or tar-ball formation. Although petrol has the best water solubility of any oil type, the dissolved fraction falls quickly as it evaporates.
Bio-based fuels are produced, for example, by gasifying biomass under oxygen-free or low-oxygen conditions, typically by fast pyrolysis; liquid or gaseous transport fuels made from biomass are defined as biofuels under EU Directive 2009/28/EC. Current response methods are aimed mainly at substances lighter than water that float and do not dissolve; bio-oil (pyrolysis oil) and other biofuels such as bioethanol and high-blend ethanol behave somewhat differently, though existing recovery methods are assumed to remain largely suitable for bio-based fuels. It is misleading to speak of biofuels as a single product group given how much their properties differ, and response to bio-oils requires ongoing research and practical testing of how their properties affect recovery equipment. In Finland the bio-content of diesel sold on the market is mostly renewable diesel, made from renewable feedstock but similar in properties to ordinary diesel, while bioethanol and E85 high-blend ethanol are volatile in a similar way to petrol. In water or wet soil bioethanol evaporates less readily than petrol because of its high water solubility, and biodegradation may be a more significant removal mechanism than evaporation; the ethanol in high-blend ethanol mixes and dissolves in water very quickly, but hydrocarbons released from it rise as a film on the surface, and ethanol mixed into water becomes noticeably more turbid than, for example, petrol. During recovery and interim storage of bio-oil it should be noted that the rapid biodegradation of high-blend ethanol produces methane as a breakdown product, and biodegradation also consumes oxygen quickly.
Heavy distillates and heavy fuel oil (HFO, No. 6 fuel oil, Bunker C and heavy sludge oils) come from the distillation residue of the refining process. Heavy distillates have a density close to or above that of water (991–1010 kg/m3) and high viscosity, and lose only about 10% of their volume to evaporation. Because of their high viscosity, heavy fuel oil is solid at normal temperature and must be heated to be pumped; in a bunkering spill, heated heavy fuel oil spreads quickly from the deck or jetty into the water, where it solidifies rapidly into a tough paste and is practically non-evaporating. Some products are too viscous to form emulsions, while others emulsify soon after a spill; they have low natural dispersion because the oil is too viscous to break into droplets, and the lowest water-soluble fraction of any oil type, so water-column loading under slicks is usually low. Heavy distillate slicks quickly break into thick ribbons and eventually into very persistent tar-ball fields; heavy distillate can travel hundreds of kilometres before finally stranding, causing significant effects on coastal vegetation and animals. Because of their high density, these oils readily sink when mixed into shoreline sediment; some heavy distillates are dense enough to be heavier than brackish water and sink quickly below the surface, making the slick hard to locate. Sunken oil travels along the bottom or in an intermediate water layer with the currents, and is a major challenge for response because booms can, in practice, only contain oil at the surface, and most skimmers only recover oil fairly close to the surface. Heavy fuel oil can form tar balls extending from the surface down tens of centimetres; brush skimmers recover heavy fuel oil more effectively than light oil because it adheres better to the brushes.
Intermediate fuel oil (IFO) typically has a density of about 890–910 kg/m3, so it floats well; its viscosity is markedly lower than that of heavy fuel oil, and it disperses more readily in waves than heavy fuel oil. Light marine fuels (MDO, MGO) are mixtures of distilled fractions: the DMX and DMA distillate grades used in shipping are known as Marine Gas Oil (MGO), and the DMB and DMC grades as Marine Diesel Oil (MDO); MDO (DMB) and MGO (DMA) have very similar properties and a shared safety data sheet. Light marine fuels are lighter than water. Low-sulphur marine fuels such as Neste RMB behave in water similarly to diesel; Neste's low-sulphur range includes Neste RMB, Neste MGO DMA and Neste MDO DMB, with RMB having a somewhat higher viscosity (8–12 mm2/s at 50°C) than the MGO and MDO grades (4–11 mm2/s at 40°C).
Vegetable oils are produced from plants such as oil palm, soybean or rapeseed, and are used in food and in biodiesel production; in the Baltic Sea they are transported by road and by sea. Vegetable oils range from free-flowing, floating oils to solidifying oils that sink. Collar skimmers are recommended for floating oils, and for example a seine net for palm kernel oil. The main environmental effect of vegetable oil spills is oxygen depletion from biodegradation of the oil, which can cause organisms to die from lack of oxygen.
LESSON 2
Properties of oil grades
Oil and most oil products are lighter than water, insoluble in water and liquid at room temperature; the heaviest oil products, such as bitumen and pitch, can be solid at room temperature, and crude oil and heavy fuel oil solidify at low temperatures. The main oil grades are crude oils, refined products, heavy fuel oils, petrol and diesel; oils can broadly be divided into persistent oils, which remain largely unchanged in nature, and non-persistent, unstable oils. Persistent oils include many crude oils and heavy refined products; non-persistent oils include naphtha, kerosene, petrol, diesel, biofuels and vegetable oils.
The most important physical properties of oil grades are density (specific gravity), which governs the oil's ability to float, and viscosity, which describes how easily oil flows and how thick it is. Other properties include the degree of evaporation, pour point, asphaltene content, dispersion, flash point and surface tension.
Oil behaviour in water depends on the relative density of the two liquids. Most oils have a lower density than fresh water (1.000) or seawater (1.025), so they float. The density of spilled oil rises over time as the lighter molecules evaporate. Floating oils weather readily, while oils heavier than water that sink are mainly subject to dissolution, so their breakdown is slow and limited.
Viscosity describes a liquid's resistance to flow: high-viscosity oils are stiff, low-viscosity oils are free-flowing, and viscosity rises as temperature falls, depending on the oil's composition. Viscosity and its change significantly affect how oil spreads in water and the thickness of the resulting slick.
The pour point is the temperature below which oil no longer flows, and depends on the oil's wax and asphaltene content: as temperature falls, wax particles crystallise, flow decreases and the oil changes from liquid to semi-solid or solid. In winter conditions the pour point matters greatly, for example indicating whether oil will gel or solidify on contact with cold water. If the water temperature is above the oil's pour point, the oil can be pumped; if the pour point is 5–10 degrees above the water temperature, the oil is likely to solidify. In autumn, when the water is warmer than the air, oil viscosity begins rising as soon as the oil is taken out of the water.
When an oil's asphaltene content is high enough, it can form an emulsion with water — alongside evaporation, one of the most important mechanisms affecting oil behaviour. In an emulsion, water droplets mix into the oil, and the volume of the oil-water emulsion grows, sometimes producing several times the original volume of oil mixture over time. The flash point is the lowest temperature at which enough vapour rises from the liquid's surface, at normal atmospheric pressure, to form a flammable vapour-air mixture when a flame is brought near it. The flash point must be taken into account during a response, especially in its early stages, since many oil grades are readily flammable until the lightest compounds have evaporated; a similar situation arises when oil is in a "confined space", such as under an ice cover.
LESSON 3
Oil behaviour over time: weathering
Once oil reaches water it begins to weather, and its composition and structure start changing immediately; over time its physical and chemical properties can differ substantially from the original oil. These weathering changes are decisive for the response operation. Oil behaviour is governed by its chemistry or composition, mainly the saturate, aromatic, asphaltene and resin fractions; on reaching water, the oil begins to weather and change state, and the changes most relevant to the response are spreading, evaporation, emulsification (water-in-oil emulsion), mixing (oil-in-water dispersion), dissolution, oxidation, sinking and sedimentation.
Evaporation is the most important change, generally causing the largest shift in the oil's mass balance and affecting other behaviour parameters; over half of a spilled light fuel oil, and even some crude oils, can evaporate within the first hours and days, and evaporation is faster in warm weather than cold. Oil can also oxidise and break down microbiologically. Significant changes in composition and properties can occur within the first 24 hours after a spill: light fractions evaporate and dissolve, and the non-evaporating residue can form an emulsion with water; the residue is denser than the original oil.
Emulsification is the second most important change. The viscosity of emulsifying oils rises quickly, typically a thousandfold, and the oil almost stops spreading and evaporating. Emulsification depends on the oil's composition: resins and asphaltenes stabilise water in the emulsion, while aromatics dissolve asphaltenes and so slow emulsification; some oils emulsify only once they have lost enough aromatics through evaporation. Natural dispersion is the third most important behaviour: the saturate fraction breaks down in very stormy conditions, while asphaltenes inhibit natural dispersion.
Because different oil grades have different properties, oils behave differently in a spill and the consequences differ accordingly; oil grade properties also affect how much contaminated soil and other oily waste is produced, how it is collected, and how it is transported and stored temporarily. Most oil grades are lighter than water, insoluble in it, and liquid at room temperature; the heaviest grades, such as bitumen and pitch, are solid at room temperature. Liquid oil is free-flowing and quickly forms a thin film that spreads over the water surface; light oil grades form the thinnest film and spread over a wider area than other grades. Oil moves in water mainly as slicks; wind and currents break up slicks so that oil travels in long, narrow streaks. The few-millimetre film of oil moves in the direction driven by wind and currents; oil on the water surface reduces wave formation and slows wave propagation, which makes it easier to locate slicks.
The speed of weathering depends on the oil type; physical properties such as viscosity and pour point; chemical properties such as wax content; the volume spilled; how much of the oil's surface is exposed to evaporation; environmental conditions such as waves, currents, ice, temperature and wind; and the oil's location, whether on or below the water surface, on, under or within ice, on shore, or mixed into shore sediment.
- Evaporation is generally the most important change and dominates the mass balance in the first hours and days after a spill.
- Emulsification greatly increases viscosity and volume and hinders mechanical recovery.
- Natural dispersion breaks oil into droplets that mix into the water column, mainly under strong wave action.
- Dissolution mainly affects the light, often highly toxic, fractions, and drops off quickly as they evaporate.
- Oil can sink and settle where its density exceeds that of water, particularly after mixing with suspended sediment in rough seas.
- Photo-oxidation from sunlight increases the potential for emulsion formation and can produce compounds toxic to aquatic organisms.
LESSON 4
Dispersion, dissolution, sinking and photo-oxidation
In dispersion, oil droplets mix into the water. The extent of dispersion depends on the oil grade, its viscosity, surface tension and the amount of mixing energy available, such as waves and turbulence. Biodiesel disperses into water more readily than ordinary diesel and also has a marked tendency to form a milky emulsion; dispersion into water can speed up biodegradation. Dispersed oil — an oil-in-water emulsion — can serve as food for plankton and micro-organisms in the sea, although the amount consumed this way is small and has little effect on the total oil budget. Dispersed oil can form a droplet layer in the water up to about two metres thick. Oil can also be deliberately broken up using dispersants; the challenge with dispersants is that the oil is not removed from nature, and the quantity of harmful chemicals actually increases. In addition, oil dispersed into the water column exposes organisms and species that would otherwise have escaped its effects. Using dispersants requires sufficiently deep water, over 20 metres, so that the dispersed oil can dilute adequately, and sufficient water exchange. For these reasons, Finnish oil-spill response legislation permits dispersant use only in exceptional cases.
Oil also dissolves in water, forming new compounds, which can themselves dissolve further, sometimes even faster than the original compound. The compounds that dissolve are usually the lighter oil fractions; because these evaporate quickly, dissolution drops off rapidly too. Generally only a small fraction of an oil's components are water-soluble, so dissolution does not greatly change the oil's overall properties, though the water-soluble components are often highly toxic and can seriously harm aquatic organisms. Petrol's solubility can be as high as 100 ppm, and heavy fuel oil's below 1 ppm.
Oil can sink if its density exceeds that of water. Sunken oil can settle in the archipelago, where water is mostly shallow; in sedimentation, oil joins deposits on the seabed and particles in the water column, smothering bottom vegetation and animals. Sedimentation requires rough seas, which mix the oil into water-column deposits and particles; oil mixed with these deposits can sink because the deposits, and any sediment mixed in, add to the oil's mass. Sunken oil breaks down very slowly and can become buried under sediment layers on the seabed. Oil can also temporarily sink and float just below the water surface, influenced by wave action, near-surface turbulence, and the oil's density and viscosity; this matters because submerged oil is hard to detect and track visually, and it weathers more slowly since it is almost always covered by a thin layer of water, so relatively fresh oil can travel hundreds of kilometres from the release point. Recovering oil floating just below the surface using standard response equipment is extremely difficult. There are three mechanisms by which submerged oil can resurface: rising water density, such as where oil moves from fresh into salt water in an estuary; the cessation of surface turbulence as wind drops; or the oil becoming stranded on shore.
Photo-oxidation is a sunlight-catalysed reaction in which the reduced carbon in the oil's hydrocarbons is oxidised. This is not, in itself, very problematic, but as photo-oxidation increases, so does the potential for water-in-oil emulsion formation, and photo-oxidised compounds are often toxic to aquatic organisms.
LESSON 5
Oil coming ashore
Oil moves under the influence of wind, surface currents and waves; a slick travels at roughly 3–4% of wind speed, and wind also affects the slick's shape, stretching it into long, narrow strips aligned with the wind. An archipelago breaks slicks up into smaller slicks; oil stranded on island shores can resume spreading if the wind direction changes. Oil spreads in the archipelago on the same principle as on the open sea, but its movement is constrained by islands and skerries; it must move between islands, sticking to their shores along the way, and the islands and skerries break slicks into smaller ones that continue moving under wind, current and wave action. As oil reaches shallower water there is a risk of it settling onto bottom vegetation.
The form oil takes on shore depends on the oil grade, the amount spilled, how long it has been in the water, and its degree of weathering. Wind and currents can pack oil into bays, increasing the thickness of the surface film. Depending on the oil type, weathered oil coming ashore can form a black, tar-like, sticky, staining material; this asphalt-like mixture may come ashore as one large slick or as individual lumps and balls. Balls are usually tar-like and a few centimetres across; lumps are generally considerably larger. Weathered oil, being heavy, may sink below the surface, in which case it can wash ashore even years later.
The eventual form of stranded oil depends on the oil's properties but also on the shore type and the conditions under which the oil came ashore, such as prevailing weather and wave action. Contributing factors include oil quality, quantity and degree of weathering, plus the dominant shore material and the steepness of the shore. How exposed an oiled shore is to wave action also affects whether oil that has already stranded is washed loose again and potentially contaminates new areas; alongside wave strength, the degree of weathering affects re-mobilisation — weathered oils, although more likely to remain on the surface of shore material, generally adhere more strongly, whereas fresh oil can wash back into the water easily.
The properties and treatability of crude oil change over time: initially liquid oil may, as the response proceeds, turn into a heavy, semi-solid material, so response must be prepared to use more than one method. For example, at sea it may be possible to use response vessels' recovery systems or floating skimmers, but once the oil has drifted ashore the material may be mainly in a form that has to be shovelled.
Despite sanctions on Russian crude oil, the volumes of crude oil transported across the Gulf of Finland have stayed roughly unchanged. The vessels used for these shipments have, however, changed: oil is now carried on older tonnage with weaker insurance cover, and the risk of an oil spill is consequently judged to be higher than before.
LESSON 6
Oil behaviour in ice conditions
Oil spreads differently in different ice conditions, which fall into three categories: open water, where the water is close to 0°C and less than 10% of the area's surface is ice; broken ice, where over 10% of the water surface is ice, including drifting ice floes, brash ice and ships' tracks; and fast ice, a continuous, unbroken ice field that may still contain leads or ships' tracks.
In cold water, oil spreads more slowly and stays in a thicker layer than in warm water, partly because the oil's viscosity is higher — it is stiffer — when cold, but mainly because ice restricts the oil's movement.
Oil among ice floes moves with the ice, the ice acting as a boom. Wind affects the oil's movement more strongly when ice floes are present than when there is only oil, so oil among drifting floes moves faster than in open water at the same wind speed. The drift speed of the ice also affects the thickness of the oil layer. Ice acts as a boom (drift ice) or a brake (rime/frazil ice), so the oil does not spread but instead stays in a thicker layer.
Where broken ice covers less than 30% of the area, oil behaves as it would in open water, with oil and ice drifting independently. Where ice cover exceeds 30%, oil and ice drift together, with some of the oil sticking to ice floes; oil attached to floes travels with them, while loose oil moves mainly with the wind. Oil that gets under ice floes rises against the ice if it is less dense than water; irregularities on the underside of the ice considerably raise the threshold needed for the oil to start moving again — sometimes requiring a current of up to 0.4 m/s. As oil breaks free of the ice it tends to move into holes, cracks and gaps between floes.
How far oil spreads on or under fast ice depends on the oil's properties, the roughness, coarseness and porosity of the ice, the prevailing temperature, and the strength of wind and current. Ice and cold slow the oil's spreading rate, so the contaminated area also ends up smaller than in the open-water season; spreading is further reduced by oil adsorbing onto ice and snow and by cavities and depressions in the ice.
Review questions
For self-study only. Answers are not recorded.
1. What is one of the most dangerous compounds in crude oil?
2. What does oil weathering mean?
Select all that apply.
3. How does oil behave in ice conditions?
Select all that apply.
4. Why does asphaltene content matter?
The certificate is issued after both the practical exercise and the final exam.