Booming and the use of booms
Step 1 — Remote study with guided digital material
Booming is normally the first response tactic deployed after an oil spill. This section covers boom selection, deployment techniques, sweeping (lassoing), shoreline and winter booming, the effect of current speed, anchoring and recovery of booms.
LESSON 1
Booming
Depending on conditions, booming can be used to restrict the spread of oil, prevent oil from entering certain areas, and/or direct the movement of oil so that it accumulates where it can be recovered as efficiently as possible.
The choice of booming method is influenced by the type of water body, current speed, shape of the shoreline, natural collection points, water depth, availability of booms, availability of labour, quantity of oil, weather and time of year.
Booms are the first oil-spill response equipment deployed after an incident. Response booms are classified by intended use, construction, operating conditions and boom size. They are used to limit the spread of oil, prevent it entering particular areas, and to direct its movement to an area where it can be efficiently collected.
Response tactics may include dynamic booming with one or more vessels, shore-anchored booming, and oil collection. Response techniques include containment, sweeping (lassoing), diversion and deflection. To contain a spill, encirclement booming, corralling and sweeping can be used, for example in U, V and J formations.
The purpose of sweeping is to gather a thin oil film together, thickening the oil layer, since mechanical recovery of a thicker oil layer is more efficient. Sweeping works best when vessels stay sufficiently close together; rather than aiming for a wide swath, it is better to sweep a narrower width repeatedly.
- Encircling a vessel: 3 × vessel length
- Collecting a vessel's oil leaks: 1.5 × vessel length
- Assisting a skimmer: 50–150 m per skimmer
- Protecting a river mouth: 3–4 × river width
- Protecting a shoreline: 1.2 × shoreline length
- Protecting a shoreline in flowing water: 1.5–2 × shoreline length, depending on the installation angle required by the current (0.4–1 m/s)
- Closing off a bay or harbour entrance: 1.5 × width of the bay mouth or harbour entrance
- Sweeping oil with boats: 150–450 m of boom for 2 boats
- In sheltered locations a single containment ring around a spill may be sufficient, but a second, outer ring is strongly recommended as a backup; it also shields the inner boom from waves and floating debris.
LESSON 2
Sweeping techniques
Sweeping can be carried out in several ways depending on the vessels available and the booms fitted to them.
An open sweep forms an enriched oil wake behind the trailing vessel, which can then be recovered efficiently. The sweep direction is usually chosen along the length of the slick, against the direction the oil is travelling. Vessels must proceed in a controlled and sufficiently slow manner once oil has been captured in the sweep, so that it is not lost under the boom. It is equally important to select a boom suited to the prevailing wave height, wind and current. Vessel speed relative to the water should be kept at about 0.5 knots, and the width of the U-sweep should be about one third of the boom length.
In J-sweeping the vessels do not advance abreast; one vessel follows slightly behind the other and simultaneously recovers oil, for example with a side collector or skimmer. J-sweeping is particularly effective when the oil slick has broken up into smaller, wake-like patches, and can also be used close to shore using shallow-draught vessels or boats.
Oil-spill response vessels usually carry a fixed sweep-boom system designed for sweeping. There are several types of sweep-boom system; most combine a fixed surface skimmer at one end of the boom for oil collection. Sweep booms are typically 6–15 metres long. The swept area of a sweep boom is smaller than that of a U- or J-sweep, but the sweep-boom system can withstand higher sweeping speeds than these techniques.
Oil can also be swept using a single vessel fitted with a sweep boom. Such a vessel has a narrower sweep width than a two-vessel sweep, but benefits from better manoeuvrability and the ability to move quickly between locations within the incident area. The collection system may be fitted on one or both sides, or a bow collector may be used instead. Single-vessel collection systems include a system permanently fitted to the vessel, comprising a sweep boom held open by a fixed or telescopic spreader arm together with a brush-belt collector. A paravane may be used instead of the sweep boom and spreader arm; paravane sweeping is relatively easy to set up and, once adjusted, holds its formation well.
LESSON 3
Booming in the shore zone
Booms can be used to prevent, restrict and/or direct the movement of oil. Oil can be diverted away from an area to be protected, or directed to a desired direction or location by anchoring the boom at an angle to the current.
By this method, oil can be directed to a shoreline where it can be recovered with skimmers, or diverted away from the shore to an area where it will not cause serious environmental contamination, or where it can be recovered more effectively.
When anchoring a boom to shore, it must be secured so that no pocket forms in which oil could accumulate. The shore anchoring must also be tight, since a fence boom generally tips over as it reaches the shore; the shore anchoring can be tightened, for example, with a sorbent boom.
Shoreline protection typically uses a containment boom alongside a sorbent boom. Shoreline protective booming should create defined areas where oil begins to accumulate, otherwise the problem is simply pushed further along; examples of such areas are the pockets formed by a zigzag boom arrangement.
When anchoring a boom on shore, weights such as stones are placed on the folded edge of the boom to make the anchoring tight.
LESSON 4
Winter conditions and booming
The use of booms is demanding in winter, particularly because ice conditions can change unexpectedly.
If the ice can bear the weight of responders and their equipment, a channel can be sawn into the ice and a deflection boom placed in it. When currents exceed 0.4 m/s, the channel is sawn at an angle to the direction of water flow, in the same way a boom would be placed in open water. The channel works even without a boom, because oil tends to rise from under the ice into open water, but a boom can be used to improve containment.
Current can be used to carry oil along a boom placed in a channel sawn into fast ice, to the end of the channel where a collection basin can be created and the oil removed, for example with a brush skimmer.
Note: the use of oil booms in broken ice is very challenging, because booms are easily damaged by the movement of ice masses.
LESSON 5
Booms and current speed
In flowing water it is important to take account of the effect of current speed on boom behaviour, anchoring, and the accumulation of oil.
It is essential to choose a boom suited to the prevailing conditions of wave height, wind and current speed. Knowing the speed and direction of the current is essential when using booms. Current meters are useful for this, but are often not available at the time of a response.
A good technique is to observe the strength of the eddies forming around buoys and marks, or debris flowing in the water. One method is to time how long it takes a piece of floating debris, or another floating object, to travel a known distance — most easily estimated using a known distance such as the length of a vessel's side.
If the critical current speed is exceeded, oil that meets the boom perpendicular to its surface at the apex escapes under the boom. Critical speed must be taken into account in every boom deployment.
Oil can escape from a boom in several ways. In strong currents, the flow against the boom creates a vortex that breaks the oil into droplets. These droplets can escape beneath the boom's skirt and rise back to the surface after passing the boom. For many oil types a current speed of below 0.5 m/s is enough to cause droplet formation and loss under the skirt. Waves increase the effect of the current, causing droplet formation and loss under the boom skirt even at lower current speeds.
Exceedance of the critical speed at the boom surface can be managed either by reducing the sweeping speed or by setting the boom at an angle to the direction of water flow, which reduces the relative speed. At high current speeds where the critical speed is exceeded, booms are used for deflection and diversion by setting them at an angle to the flow direction; for example, a 45-degree angle reduces the relative current speed against the boom by about half.
LESSON 6
Booming in river and strait formations
Current must always be taken into account when planning booming. The following are various options for booming in flowing conditions.
- Multiple deflection booming
- Deflection booming with a paravane
- Deflection booming using a winch line
- V-shaped booming, anchored at the centre, with oil collection on both sides of the boom
- Open V-shaped booming with oil collection on both sides of the boom
- V-shaped booming where oil collection takes place mainly from a collection vessel
LESSON 7
Boom anchoring and deployment
An oil-spill response boom can be anchored using three different techniques: (1) free anchoring, (2) shore anchoring, and (3) pier anchoring.
Response booms can be anchored from their end sections, or connected to anchor points along the full length of the boom. Sections of boom used to protect a shoreline may need several anchor points along the length of the protective boom. Prevailing wind and current conditions, combined with the strength of currents, directly affect the number of anchoring systems needed during a response.
A mooring buoy allows response personnel to stay dry and safe inside the boat while lowering and raising the boom. Mooring buoys also prevent the anchor from pulling the boom below the water surface.
The rope between the mooring buoy and the anchor should be at least 3 times the water depth. This is a good rule of thumb for calm water conditions. In wavy water conditions, the length should be adjusted to 5 times the water depth.
Consider using lights along the boom line so that boaters can identify it and its position can be monitored at night.
- Prepare an anchoring plan taking account of wind, waves, currents, tides, water depth, bottom conditions and vessel traffic in the area.
- Select a suitable anchor type and set anchors and mooring lines before lowering the boom into the water. Mark anchor points with buoys.
- When moving the boom, take care that it is not dragged against a rough surface. Sufficient manpower must be used to lift boom sections to the water's edge or into a work boat.
- Place the leading edge of the boom closest to the waterline and lay the boom in a concertina (accordion) pattern so it can be pulled into the water easily without friction or wear.
- Connect the boom sections on land (or in the work boat). The aluminium connectors at both ends of the boom must be joined and locked together with connector pins. Tow the boom carefully out using the tow head.
- Secure the boom to the appropriate anchor points according to the plan. The boom's tow heads can also be used as sturdy end-connection points.
- A floating sorbent boom can be used together with an oil boom. Place the sorbent boom alongside the containment boom, on the side exposed to oil.
- Monitor the deployed boom to ensure the anchors hold the boom in the intended position, and adjust as necessary.
LESSON 8
Boom recovery
The recovery of a boom follows a defined sequence of steps.
- Release one end of the boom and connect it to the towing vessel.
- Release all subsequent anchor points and tow the protective boom to shore, or pull the boom aboard the work boat.
- Use enough manpower so that every section of the protective boom is stacked into a tidy bundle in a concertina (zigzag) pattern.
- Secure each section to fasten it for transport.
- Take care when lifting and gathering each boom section to avoid dragging, which can damage the boom.
- Lay out each boom section in a suitable place for cleaning, rinsing and drying. Blow air into each chain chamber to remove any residual water.
- Once the boom has dried completely, refold each segment into a concertina or similar pattern and store the boom safely for storage and later use.
- If the boom has been exposed to oil during use, the cost-benefit of cleaning the contaminated boom versus replacing it should be assessed. If replacement is the more economical option, the contaminated boom must be disposed of in accordance with environmental law.
LESSON 9
Summary of booming and protection methods
Excessive current speed and/or waves cause problems in booming, as oil passes under or over the boom. This can be addressed by towing or setting the boom according to current speed, choosing a more effective (larger) boom, or using the boom in more sheltered conditions or locations.
- Establish the current speeds and directions in the area, and the wind direction and speed. Take account of forecasts several days ahead.
- Estimate the direction and speed of movement of the oil slick and the targets at risk of contamination.
- 90% of the oil is located in 10% of the slick's surface area, and the remaining 10% of the oil is spread over 90% of the area — focus your resources accordingly.
- Prioritise the targets to be protected in order to maximise the benefit of limited boom resources.
- Establish containment, protection, deflection or diversion booming as appropriate.
- Determine which targets are best protected by a fixed anchored boom and which by dynamic booming, i.e. boom controlled from vessels.
- Select the boom type according to the water depth, degree of shelter and current conditions in the area; choose a boom whose draught is at most 1/3 of the water depth, with an optimum draught of 1/5 of the water depth.
- The amount of boom needed to encircle a casualty vessel is 3–6 times the vessel's length; if possible, assemble a closed sweep from an odd number of boom sections.
- Sweep-boom length: 100–500 metres.
- Keep the width of the sweep mouth at a maximum of 1/3 of the sweep length.
- Critical speed: 0.5 knots (speed relative to the water).
- Monitor the performance of the booms and the holding of the anchors.
- Recover as much oil as possible.
Review questions
For self-study only. Answers are not recorded.
1. Why is an oil boom used?
Select all that apply.
2. What matters in the design/construction of oil booms?
Select all that apply.
3. Where does the name 'J-sweep' come from?
Answer key awaiting instructor review.
4. Why is it important to choose a boom suited to the prevailing conditions (waves, wind, current)?
Select all that apply.
Answer key awaiting instructor review.
5. What is the minimum length of rope between the mooring buoy and the anchor in calm weather?
The certificate is issued after both the practical exercise and the final exam.