Oil-spill response equipment

Step 1 — Remote study with guided digital material

An overview of oil-spill response equipment: boom types and selection, mechanical skimmers, pumps, power units, temporary storage, containerised equipment sets and response vessels.

LESSON 1

Boom types and selecting the right boom

Oil booms are classified by intended use, construction, operating conditions and size. By intended use, booms are divided into general-purpose booms and special-purpose booms. General-purpose booms are versatile and are used to contain the spread of oil and for sweeping (herding oil for recovery). Special-purpose booms are designed for specific sites or applications, such as sweep booms used for concentrating oil.

Oil booms must be flexible in construction while also being able to resist tension, withstanding the stress forces created by waves and currents. When planning the use of booms, the environmental factors acting on the boom must be taken into account; the most significant of these are current and wave action.

The construction principle is broadly the same across most boom models. A boom consists of a floatation section and a skirt, and includes a chain, rope or webbing that receives the horizontal pulling load on the boom. The chain at the lower edge also acts as ballast, keeping the boom upright. In most boom models, two-thirds of the boom's height sits below the waterline and one-third above it. Booms are held in place by anchoring, by being attached to a towing vessel, or by being secured to the shore.

Booms are connected to one another using connectors, and most boom models use ASTM connectors, named after the ASTM International standards organisation — for example the ASTM top- or bottom-loading slide connector and the Z-connector. Some connector types have male and female ends at opposite ends of the boom, which must be taken into account when joining several booms together in the water. Booms also have a towing head, from which the boom is towed.

Booms can be broadly divided into three types: fence booms, curtain booms and special-purpose booms. They can also be divided by area of use into offshore, coastal, river or shoreline booms. Special-purpose booms include, for example, fire booms, net booms and water-filled shore-protection booms. In general, curtain booms are more versatile than fence booms.

  • Fence booms
  • Curtain booms
  • Special-purpose booms

LESSON 2

Classification by size and operating conditions

Fence booms are generally flat and fairly rigid or completely rigid in the vertical direction, with floats that are either solid — for example made of closed-cell foam — or filled with granules. Because of their lower price, fence booms are fairly common, but they are suitable only for very sheltered waters. They are typically prone to poor wave-following (heave response) because of their low buoyancy reserve and rigidity. Rigid fence booms are not recommended for use in flowing water, wind or waves.

Curtain booms perform better than fence booms in waves and flowing water because they follow wave motion more nimbly. A disadvantage of inflatable curtain booms, typically ocean booms, is their somewhat slower deployment, as their compartments are filled one at a time. In models with individually inflatable sections, however, the rupture of one chamber does not compromise the whole boom's function. Some curtain booms are inflated from a single connector at one end of the boom; these too are generally designed with compartmentalised chambers.

Permanently filled (solid buoyancy) booms have the advantage of low susceptibility to damage and a relatively low purchase price, but they require a great deal of storage space, and if packed incorrectly some can be damaged, for example by being crushed. This boom type is also available ready-packed in its own storage bag as a quick-deployment boom; a length of boom can be towed at relatively high speed to the incident site and deployed there as required.

Shore-protection booms are built from three tubular chambers, of which the two lower ones are water-filled and act as ballast. This boom is intended particularly for areas where water level varies or where the shore has an extended shallow area. The boom floats in water but presses tightly against the ground at the shoreline, giving it reliable performance, provided the shoreline has no rocks or other features that could puncture and damage the boom.

Booms with rectangular floats do not follow waves very well. This category includes, among others, heavy-duty fixed-float fence booms intended for long-term or permanent booming. Fixed-flotation booms work in calm water but also in ice conditions and withstand loading from drifting ice or debris well.

There are many kinds of special-purpose boom. One example is the V-shaped sweep boom, built from different zones that assist rapid and efficient collection of oil without it escaping under the boom.

LESSON 3

Mechanical oil recovery — skimmers

Mechanical recovery includes brush-based collection, in which oil is recovered from water, rock, stone surfaces, constructed surfaces and ice using collectors of many kinds and sizes, operated as vessel-, crane-, excavator-, harvester- or hand-operated recovery systems. Mechanical recovery methods also include machine-based techniques such as land stripping, skimming, pumping, vacuum suction and sorbent application. The advantage of mechanical recovery is speed and reduced labour requirements; however, environmental impacts on land and along the shoreline can be significant. Mechanical recovery can increase soil erosion, damage vegetation and spread contamination to clean areas, for example via oil carried on vehicle tyres.

Skimmers operate on one of four principles: oil adhering to a moving oleophilic surface on the collector (oleophilic skimmers); oil flowing over a weir into a collector below the surface (weir skimmers); suction by the collector (suction skimmers); or transfer of an oil-water mixture towards the collector (hydrodynamic skimmers). Adhesion-based skimmers generally recover medium and heavy oils better, while weir-based skimmers recover light and medium oils better.

Oleophilic collectors whose collecting surface moves include disk, drum and brush types. Oil on the water surface adheres to the brushes, disks or drum, from which it is wiped into the collector by the rotating motion. Disk and drum collectors suit medium and, in part, light oils. Brush collectors work well for heavy and medium oils and, by increasing rotation speed, can also recover lighter oils. Brush collectors have also been developed for lighter, more fluid oil grades by varying bristle size, structure and material. Adhesion-based collectors have parallel brushes, disks or drums rotating on their own axes, arranged for example in a triangular, square or circular frame.

Some collectors are built so that the recovery unit is interchangeable, allowing the same collector to be fitted with brush, drum or disk units. Brush, disk and drum collectors are available as floating units, boom-controlled units, and units with their own propulsion and remote control, including Ex-protected controllers. Other adhesion-based collector types include rope mops, sorbent lifting belts, submersion plane/belt collectors that push oil beneath the surface, and paddle-belt collectors fitted with lifting paddles.

Weir skimmers work on the overflow principle and are especially suited to recovering light oil from calm water. Their drawback is a poor oil-to-water recovery ratio, meaning they recover a great deal of water along with the oil. Weir skimmers with automatic draught adjustment are a better option in this respect, but even their recovered material may contain 70–90% water. Both simple and self-adjusting weir skimmers are prone to blocking from floating debris. Skimmers fitted with a built-in screw pump, by contrast, continue to work in debris-laden water; this type also recovers medium oils, but as with other weir-based skimmers the recovered material has a high water content. The heavier the oil grade being recovered, the more likely it is that oil will need to be pushed over the weir into the sump using hand tools. Some weir skimmers are fitted with a centrifugal pump, which can readily emulsify the recovered oil.

Skimmer selection is affected by oil viscosity and slick thickness, the sheltered nature and temperature of the water body, and any debris or ice on the surface. Skimmers work more efficiently the thicker the oil layer being recovered; sufficient layer thickness is achieved by herding or sweeping oil from a wider area into a thicker layer within reach of the collector. Skimmer recovery performance is described by maximum recovery capacity and the oil content of the recovered material, and varies with skimmer type, pump power, recovery conditions, oil type, degree of weathering, oil layer thickness and slick continuity. The actual recovery rate of a skimmer in the field rarely matches the manufacturer's test-based figure, mainly because of the difference between test-tank and field conditions, particularly the fact that oil in the field spreads and fragments into a discontinuous slick, unlike the continuous slick in a test tank.

LESSON 4

Suction and transfer pumps

Pump capacity depends mainly on oil viscosity; recovery rate falls as temperature drops and viscosity rises. In oil-spill response, pumps are subjected to heavy loading, as the oil may carry a great deal of solid matter. Requirements placed on pumps depend on the transfer distances and lift heights needed. When a pump is used to transfer an oil-water mixture from a skimmer to a temporary tank, a lift height of 2–6 metres is usually sufficient. Pumping or suction always draws in some water, more with some techniques and less with others. Oil, being lighter than water, rises to the surface, so water remaining at the bottom of the tank can be drawn off as needed and passed through an oil separator back to the water body or to a separate tank.

A screw pump (Archimedes type) is also suitable for pumping very heavy oil. Water injection can also be used to assist pumps designed for it. Lamor operates a test tank where pumps' actual capacity can be tested and accredited; in one such test conducted well into the low temperatures of autumn, the oil behaved like bitumen.

LESSON 5

Recovering oil on land or on the shoreline

Vacuum techniques are used to recover oil that has pooled or been directed by flushing or other washing methods into a collection pit or trench. Suction can be provided by liquid vacuum tankers, slurry tankers or cesspit emptying vehicles. The load-bearing capacity of the shore may limit the use of heavy vehicles, which can sometimes be compensated for with long transfer hoses. The most common hose length is 20–30 metres, but suction distances of over 100 metres are also possible. With long suction hoses, the method also suits areas with no road access to the shore, and can be used from a barge, raft or ferry.

Vacuum methods are effective and fast for recovering large volumes of oil, provided the oil-to-water recovery ratio can be kept favourable. This requires that the oil has been collected into a pit from which water has been drained, or that it has pooled into a thick layer. Vacuum methods suit oils of various viscosities, other than very stiff ones, and tolerate debris. Vacuum recovery reduces the risk of oil-water emulsion because it recovers oil 'gently'. Selective recovery from water is challenging, as it requires the suction hose to be held precisely at water level; when the oil layer is thin, selective recovery becomes more difficult and a large amount of water is drawn in along with it. Water must be separated out to reduce transport and storage requirements. For safety reasons, vacuum suction must not be used on readily volatile oils.

Additional devices are available for vacuum recovery, such as the Manta Ray skimmer, which floats the suction head at water level. This flat, hemispherical device has several suction channels and is suited to light oils. Its recovery performance is good in calm water when the oil layer is thicker than 5 mm. Its top cover is removable if the skimmer becomes clogged with debris.

Hand-held brush collectors, known as rock cleaners, carried like a strimmer or brushcutter, can also be used for shoreline cleaning. Operating a rock cleaner requires assisting personnel, as handling long hoses in the field is physically demanding, especially when they are full of oil.

LESSON 6

Sorbent (absorbent) methods

Sorbent methods also suit sensitive habitats. Their environmental impact is very limited, arising mainly from personnel movement in the area, especially where reusable sorbent materials that are easy to recover are used. Sorbents can be used both for protection and for recovery, and can be used on light and medium oils for as long as the oil remains liquid, or at least sticky.

In water, sorbent materials used include sorbent booms, sorbent pads or sheets. Shore-protection mats are useful alongside washing techniques and for protecting surrounding areas from secondary contamination. Loose sorbent materials such as sorbent granulate, peat, sawdust or woodchip should not be used in water, as they are difficult to handle, especially to recover, and organic loose materials generally sink. Sorbent granulate can be used on solid surfaces; near the waterline it should be collected as soon as possible so it is not carried off by waves, water-level changes or wind.

Rescue services most commonly hold pad-type sorbent booms. Their effectiveness can be increased by fastening two sorbent pads together side by side with cable ties, which stops the boom rolling and releasing oil from beneath it. Sorbent pad booms are recommended only for sheltered shores in water flowing at less than 0.1–0.2 m/s; in waves, the boom tends to ride up onto rocks, reducing its containment and recovery performance. A flat sorbent strip boom, by contrast, follows waves better and also offers a large sorption surface area. Despite its name, a pad-type sorbent boom is not a boom but a recovery aid; because of its shallow draught it does not contain the spread of oil.

A skirted sorbent boom made of sorbent fabric is also sold for protection, formed like an upright boom; it is useful particularly in spills where oil sinks into the water column. A sorbent pad fitted with a containment-boom skirt is also manufactured. Sorbent materials are mainly used once the bulk of the oil has already been recovered by other methods. Where there is a large amount of oil, sorbents saturate quickly and must be changed often, which increases both workload and waste volume.

Some sorbent materials can be reused. Sorbents are easily overused: often, for example, the inside of a sorbent pad boom remains completely white. This is also caused by viscous oils, which coat the boom so that oil cannot penetrate deeper. Sometimes tightly packed sorbent pads and booms are ineffective because of excessive compactness; oil does not absorb to the maximum extent when the available sorption surface area is small. Sorbents are also suitable for mud and silt shores, where the use of other methods is more limited.

LESSON 7

Power units

Hydraulic power for oil-spill response equipment is typically supplied by a diesel-driven power unit. Smaller power units are wheel-mounted and fitted with towing or push handles. Larger power units, rated at tens of kilowatts, require mechanical lifting capacity by crane and can only be moved by trailer and/or are housed in a container for transport.

LESSON 8

Temporary storage

Recovered oil can be temporarily stored, for example, in floating tanks when oil is being recovered from a water body. On the shore zone, collapsible tanks can be set up at oil-collection points; it is good practice to place sorbent mats underneath the tanks. Rescue services may also have access to, or be able to procure, barges or floating stores of their own for storing recovered oil.

LESSON 9

Equipment sets

Many rescue services hold oil-spill response equipment kept ready for use in standard containers, which simplifies transport and deployment. Booms can be stored and transported to the incident site in containers together with the additional equipment needed for their use, such as anchors, ropes and marker buoys for the booms. Oil-spill response equipment can also be mounted on and transported by trailer.

Containers can also be equipped with a system enabling rapid initial response; such containers carry a fence boom, an oil skimmer, a transfer pump, oil-recovery hoses, a diesel-hydraulic power unit, hydraulic hoses and sorbent boom. Another container type holds equipment, tools and materials suited to shoreline recovery: a rock cleaner with accessories, sorbent pads and sorbent boom.

LESSON 10

Oil-spill response vessels

Many types of vessels and boats can be used to combat oil that has spilled onto water. A vessel's size, towing capacity, draught, deck space and storage capacity determine its suitability for different oil-spill response tasks.

The shallow draught of oil-spill response boats allows them to be used effectively both close to shore and elsewhere in shallow water.

Vessels taking part in oil-spill response must have certain structural features. They cannot have a conventional cooling system based on an open seawater intake, since oil floating on the surface or suspended in the water column would clog the seawater intakes and filters, and would form a film on the engine's heat exchanger that impairs heat transfer.

Review questions

For self-study only. Answers are not recorded.

  1. 1. Why are oil booms used?

    Select all that apply.

  2. 2. What matters in the design of oil booms?

    Select all that apply.

  3. 3. In what conditions can fence booms be recommended for use?

    Answer key awaiting instructor review.

  4. 4. Why is it important to choose a boom suited to the prevailing conditions (waves, wind, current)?

    Select all that apply.

    Answer key awaiting instructor review.

3D equipment viewer

The certificate is issued after both the practical exercise and the final exam.