Oil-spill response strategy
Step 1 — Remote study with guided digital material
Oil-spill response strategy: how response is organised and supervised, how protected targets are prioritised, the time phases of a response, and cooperation between authorities and volunteers.
LESSON 1
Organising and supervising oil-spill response
After an oil spill, oil booms are among the first response equipment deployed. Booms are used to limit the spread of oil, to keep it out of specific areas, and to steer its movement to a location where it can be recovered efficiently. Booms can also be used for sweeping oil into a slick thick enough for mechanical recovery to work effectively. In archipelagos and near the coast, booms are used to prevent and limit oil from reaching areas that need protection, such as bird nesting sites, bathing beaches and fish farms. It is important to continue limiting the spread of oil even after it has reached the shore, so that the contaminated shoreline does not grow further. In some cases the spread of oil can be prevented by booming it into bays or straits between islands, from which it can then be recovered mechanically.
The primary response measures on water are: dynamic booming by one or more vessels in open water, shore-attached booming, and oil recovery. Response techniques that can be applied include containment, sweeping, steering and directing. Containment can use encirclement booming, pincer formations and sweeping, for example in U, V and J formations. A boom deployment is created by forming two protective rings, leaving enough space between them for any oil that escapes the first ring to surface.
Sweeping is made considerably more effective if aerial reconnaissance can be used to direct vessels to the thickest part of the oil slick. Sweeping works best when the vessels stay close enough together; rather than aiming for a wide sweep width, it is better to sweep a narrower width several times. Oil droplets or patches rising to the surface behind the boom indicate that the sweep is leaking. Water eddies forming behind the sweep also indicate excessive sweep speed. The bight of the boom cannot be seen from the towing vessels, so boat- or air-based reconnaissance must be used to monitor it.
When sweeping or booming, the current speed at the boom must not exceed half a knot, roughly 0.3 m/s. This is called the critical velocity. When this speed is exceeded, oil meeting the boom surface at right angles in the bight escapes underneath the boom. This happens even if the boom remains upright — the phenomenon does not require the boom to capsize or submerge. The critical-velocity threshold depends on both the boom's construction and the type of oil.
In flowing water, booms are used for steering and directing by placing the boom at an angle to the current so that the relative speed at the boom surface is reduced. This angling requires a longer boom than the length of the target being protected or the width of the watercourse. For example, in a narrow channel with a high current speed, a boom three to four times the width of the watercourse may be needed. At high current speeds, several booms are needed to stop the oil: the first boom absorbs most of the current force, so the flow is already somewhat slower at the next boom, giving it much greater reliability.
When protecting areas, it must be remembered that protecting one area can easily cause contamination of neighbouring areas if the oil's movement cannot be halted. Efforts should therefore focus on creating areas where oil is allowed to accumulate and from which it is then removed. An oil spill in flowing water will spread and travel over a wide area unless it can be contained or directed to shore for collection. The stopping point is chosen in a more slowly flowing area, such as a river backwater or a bay, taking into account the sensitivity of the area, how easily it can be cleaned, and logistical constraints. The stopping point is protected with a shoreline boom and absorbent material before the oil is guided ashore. Successful booming is challenged by the speed at which oil travels, the slick breaking into several parts, and the effect of currents, wind and waves on the boom's performance. The type of boom is chosen according to the depth, shelter and current conditions of the water body.
LESSON 2
Oil-spill response on shorelines
The first areas to be cleaned are those with the most oil, or those that are particularly sensitive to oil. Heavily oiled areas pose a risk that oil will wash off again and contaminate new areas. The response commander, or a clean-up assessment team authorised by them, decides on the need for clean-up, the order in which areas are cleaned, and the choice of clean-up methods. The operational site supervision is responsible for the practical application of the chosen methods according to conditions.
When assessing shoreline clean-up, consideration must be given to whether clean-up is needed at all, and if so, at what intensity. The benefits and drawbacks of each clean-up method must be weighed against leaving the area unclean or against supported natural recovery. The most effective, selective and discriminating method available should be chosen for recovering the oil.
Oil recovery methods can be divided into manual, mechanical, machine-based and washing-based methods, plus natural recovery. At the start of clean-up work, collectors on site are briefed on the methods chosen for each work site and on waste sorting and separation practices. Experts assess the effectiveness of the clean-up work and the oil content of the collected waste, refining the clean-up instructions as necessary.
Clean-up work should be carried out in a systematic manner: work and move from clean areas towards dirty ones. Prevent contamination from spreading along the shoreline. Where the prioritisation of areas allows, start clean-up work upstream, so that if oil washes back into the water it does not soil already cleaned areas; this method is also followed within a single stretch of shoreline. To prevent the spread of oil, always place a containment boom off the collection work site, so that oil or absorbent materials washed into the water can be recovered in a controlled way.
Prevent contamination from spreading from the shore inland: plan and protect access routes used, set up decontamination points for those leaving the dirty work site, and restrict unnecessary traffic. Supervise the sorting of oily waste from the very start of the chain, provide enough containers, mark them clearly, and keep records of waste collected and transported. Do not mix unoiled and oily waste. Do not needlessly mix heavily oil-contaminated and lightly oil-contaminated materials together.
When a work site is closed, a report on the measures carried out there is compiled for the response management. The report describes the measures taken, the workforce and equipment used, and any areas identified for improvement; it is used in preparing compensation claims. Response management must instruct site supervisors on what information must be recorded and which documents must be retained. The response commander decides, after consulting the supervising environmental authority, when oil-spill response no longer requires action by the response authority. The end of response is verified case by case for each shoreline area and each intermediate storage site through separate inspections.
To make the collection and handling of oily waste as efficient as possible, it is good practice to arrange proper facilities at collection sites both for the actual oil recovery and for sorting the oily waste, as well as for other support functions such as catering and sanitation.
LESSON 3
Prioritising oil-spill response
Directing response efforts and choosing between targets to protect becomes operationally challenging when there is a large number of different targets requiring protection. Response management has very limited time to assess which targets can realistically be protected with the available resources under prevailing conditions. A prior survey of priority nature sites needing protection considerably improves the ability of oil-spill response authorities to take sensitive nature sites into account when planning response and combating environmental damage.
- Raw-water intake points (municipal water intake, process and cooling water intake)
- Nature conservation sites (bird and mammal colonies and similar)
- Shorelines that are difficult to clean, such as wetlands, foreshore and mud areas, whose natural environment is both vulnerable to damage and valuable in its own right
- Scientific research stations
- Bathing beaches and the shores of camping and recreation areas
- Inhabited shores and the shores of tourism businesses
- Fish farms
- Boat and fishing harbours
LESSON 4
Time phases of oil-spill response
Measures triggered by an oil spill are divided into four main phases: initial response, early-phase response, follow-up response, and restoration. Rescue services are generally responsible for oil-spill response in their area, including coastal areas, while the Border Guard is responsible for operations on the open sea. This basic course focuses primarily on preparedness for oil-spill response and on phases 1–2: initial response and early-phase response.
The legislation applicable to the different phases of oil-spill response, the authority responsible for the work, and that authority's powers can differ between phases. Early-phase response and follow-up response differ from restoration in that the Rescue Act applies to them. During both early-phase response and follow-up response, the authority in charge can, if necessary, require other operators to make available sufficient transport equipment or areas for loading and temporary storage of waste. In the restoration phase, authorities do not have such extended powers.
In practice, oil-spill response means preventing, containing and directing the spread of oil, protecting targets prone to contamination such as shorelines, and recovering oil from the surface of water or ground. Response measures also include removing oil and carrying out rough clean-up of the contaminated area — that is, collecting loose oil and handling, storing and transporting it in a controlled manner so that there is no longer a risk of renewed oiling or of the damage spreading. Follow-up response comprises the more detailed finishing clean-up of shorelines and fine clean-up of special targets.
Initial response comprises the response measures that the party who caused the damage may themselves reasonably be required to carry out given the circumstances, such as stopping or slowing the leak by pumping the oil away, or moving the point of damage into a more favourable position, for example by changing a ship's trim or list.
Early-phase oil-spill response begins as soon as the authorities are notified of the accident. It includes containing the damage, preventing further damage, and recovering oil together with the logistics that support this. Early-phase response work is the responsibility of the rescue authority, while follow-up response is the responsibility of the local municipality. The rescue operation commander decides when early-phase oil-spill response ends and the transition to follow-up response takes place. Before making this decision, the rescue operation commander must ensure that the municipal authorities have sufficient capacity to handle the follow-up response for the spill in question. The decision to transfer response responsibility must always be made in writing and in agreement with the party taking over responsibility. At this stage the rescue service may consult and/or inform the relevant ELY Centre (Centre for Economic Development, Transport and the Environment).
Follow-up response begins once the rescue operation commander has announced that early-phase response measures have ended and that command responsibility has been transferred to the municipal authority responsible for follow-up response. The various municipal authorities and agencies must participate in follow-up response as necessary, and municipal authorities may use the rescue service or consultancy services to carry out follow-up response work. The aim of follow-up response is more thorough clean-up of the contaminated shoreline area. The ELY Centre guides and coordinates follow-up response work if the response extends across several municipalities. The authority in charge of follow-up response decides, after consulting the ELY Centre if necessary, when response to the oil spill can be concluded.
Restoration follows on from oil-spill response but is no longer response in the proper sense. Restoration refers to the measures that follow if, once response work has ended, environmental remediation has not achieved a sufficiently good outcome and remediation must be continued as restoration under the provisions of the Environmental Protection Act. Restoration means returning a water area, coastline, soil or groundwater damaged by the spill to the condition it was in before the damage occurred.
The urgent work phases of oil-spill response — alerting, containing the damage, and recovering oil that is not yet bound — are carried out by rescue service personnel. This part of the response work, which is largely dictated by conditions and available options, is led by the oil-spill response authority, that is, the rescue authorities of the relevant rescue service area, who are to be given expert assistance by the environmental centre as necessary.
Once the spread of the damage has been contained, the next work phase is cleaning the contaminated area, carried out — depending on the wellbeing services county — by technical department and rescue service personnel jointly or separately. Because the damage has usually by then reached its main extent, the measures best suited to the purpose can be chosen and carried out without being constrained by lack of time.
The environmental centre must, where necessary, provide expert assistance to the response authority (the area's rescue service and/or the body designated for follow-up response) in planning these clean-up measures. In a damage case this is necessary, for example, when studies of the damage's effects are needed, when the required clean-up measures are unclear, when clean-up requires special methods, or when the clean-up work turns out to be exceptionally costly.
LESSON 5
Cooperation between authorities and volunteers
Volunteer resources form an important additional resource in responding to a major oil spill. The more organised the cooperation between authorities and volunteers is, the more effective the support the response operation receives. For this reason, a plan for using volunteers should form part of the oil-spill response plan. It should record information on the area's volunteer organisations, the human resources available and their specialist skills. It is also useful to know in advance what equipment and gear volunteers have available, since the resources and skills of regional organisations affect the usability of volunteers even where the relevant expertise exists nationally.
Volunteer tasks for which ready expertise exists nationally fall into two groups.
- Operational tasks: reconnaissance duties, shoreline response, collection and clean-up, oil sampling, care of oiled animals
- Logistics and other support functions: transport, building and dismantling of staging areas, catering, accommodation and first aid, equipment issue, registering volunteers, forming groups, briefing volunteers, and identifying special skills in support of the authorities
Review questions
For self-study only. Answers are not recorded.
1. After an oil spill in a body of water, which are among the first oil-spill response tools used?
Answer key awaiting instructor review.
2. Which of the following belong to the main phases of measures triggered by an oil spill?
Select all that apply.
Answer key awaiting instructor review.
3. Which of the following is not a suitable oil-spill response task for volunteers?
Answer key awaiting instructor review.
4. What is the critical current speed at a boom that should not be exceeded when sweeping or booming?
5. When is final and fine shoreline clean-up started?
Select all that apply.
The certificate is issued after both the practical exercise and the final exam.